Who this comparison is for
Mid-market merchants where interchange at cost with a flat subscription (Stax) becomes the cheapest published price, and an independent ISO quote is worth pricing against it.
Recommended processors for $100K to $250K monthly
The 4 processors below are ordered by published cost and fit at this volume. Effective rates come from our cost engine: a $50 average sale, 60% credit and 40% debit cards, prices checked Oct 2026. See the methodology page for full assumptions.
1. Stax
1.79% in person, 2.08% online at $250KSubscription IC-plusBest for
Steady volume at this tier: interchange at cost plus 8¢ in person or 15¢ online and a $199+ subscription. The cheapest published price in our engine at $250K a month, in person and online.
Watch out for
Stax publishes its fee above $250K a year only as $199+ and does not publish its contract length, so get both in writing.
2. Helcim
1.94% in person, 2.45% online at $250KInterchange-plus with automatic volume discountsBest for
Merchants who want no monthly fee and no contract. Interchange + 0.25% + 7¢ in person and 0.35% + 20¢ online from $100K a month.
Watch out for
At $250K a month Stax costs $375 less in person ($4,475 vs $4,850) and $925 less online ($5,200 vs $6,125) in our engine.
3. Negotiated IC++ from an independent ISO
Not published (quote only)Custom interchange-plus-plusBest for
Operators willing to run a 3-quote process. ISOs such as Payment Depot (a registered ISO of Wells Fargo Bank, N.A.) quote interchange-plus; sign only if the quote beats Stax's and Helcim's published prices.
Watch out for
Read the contract for early termination fees and liquidated damages, which is where an ISO can claw back a negotiated discount.
4. Adyen
2.56% online (interchange++ + 0.60% + 13¢)Enterprise interchange-plusBest for
International and cross-border merchants where Adyen's unified processing across regions is unique.
Watch out for
Adyen applies a minimum monthly invoice it does not publish, and setup needs developer work. At its published rate it costs $6,400 online at $250K, more than Stax ($5,200) and Helcim ($6,125).
Pricing-model breakdown at $100K to $250K monthly
At $100K to $250K monthly, three pricing models compete: flat rate, interchange-plus with a percentage markup, and subscription interchange-plus with a monthly fee and no percentage markup. Here is the math on each.
Tier 1
Custom IC++ (quote)
Negotiated through 3 ISOs
Quote-based. No published rates. Ask for no monthly fee.
Best for
$100K to $250K monthly with a stable processing history. Worth it only if the quote beats Stax's published price.
What’s included
- ·Price every quote against Stax's and Helcim's published rates
- ·Negotiable contract terms (push: no ETF, no auto-renewal, capped reserve)
- ·Ask whether PCI, statement and regulatory fees can be waived
- ·Get the full fee schedule in writing
- ·Run the 3-quote process every 24 months at minimum
Tier 2
Subscription, interchange at cost
Stax
$199+ monthly + interchange + 8¢ in person, 15¢ online (no percentage markup)
Best for
The cheapest published price at this tier in our engine: $4,475 in person and $5,200 online at $250K a month.
What’s included
- ·No percentage markup over interchange
- ·Next business day funding
- ·Predictable monthly subscription
- ·Contract length not published: ask in writing
- ·Hardware sold separately (SwipeSimple reader $125, Dejavoo QD4 $310)
Tier 3
Enterprise IC++
Adyen / Worldpay (negotiated)
Adyen: interchange++ + 0.60% + 13¢ (Visa and Mastercard), minimum invoice not published. Worldpay: no published rates
Best for
$200K to $250K monthly with international or cross-border volume or complex use cases.
What’s included
- ·Unified cross-border processing (Adyen)
- ·Worldpay is part of Global Payments since January 2026
- ·Ask for the minimum invoice and contract terms in writing
- ·Engineering-heavy onboarding
- ·Best for mid-market with developer resources
The actual math at $100K to $250K monthly
At $250,000 a month (the top of this tier and a point in our engine, at a $50 average sale and 60% credit, 40% debit), the monthly cost in person runs: Stax $4,475, Helcim $4,850, PayPal POS $6,175, Clover $6,325, Square $6,900 (Premium plan), Stripe Terminal $7,000. Online: Stax $5,200, Helcim $6,125, Adyen $6,400, PayPal Advanced card $8,675, Stripe and Square $8,750. Stax saves $375 a month in person and $925 online over Helcim, and $1,700 to $2,525 in person and $3,475 to $3,550 online over flat rate. At $50,000, the point below this tier, Helcim was still cheaper in person ($1,020 vs $1,055), so check where your volume sits. Independent ISO quotes publish no rates, so we cannot put them in this math. Interchange-plus figures rest on our interchange estimate (1.55% in person, 1.70% online).
Sources
- myPayAdvisor 2026 Payment Processor Effective Rate Database: open dataset, CC-BY-4.0. View
- myPayAdvisor Research Methodology: card-mix assumption, sample selection, calculation method. View
- Processor public pricing pages (checked Oct 29, 2026): Stripe, Square, Helcim, PayPal, Stax, Adyen, Clover, Authorize.net, Braintree, Shopify Payments. Payment Depot and Worldpay publish no merchant rates.