Who this comparison is for
Established SMBs and growing mid-market merchants where every basis point matters and rate negotiation becomes worth doing.
Recommended processors for $50K to $100K monthly
The 4 processors below are ordered by published cost and fit at this volume. Effective rates come from our cost engine: a $50 average sale, 60% credit and 40% debit cards, prices checked Oct 2026. See the methodology page for full assumptions.
1. Helcim
2.04% in person, 2.55% online at $50KInterchange-plus with automatic volume discountsBest for
In-person businesses near the bottom of this tier. Interchange + 0.35% + 7¢ in person from $50K, falling to 0.25% + 7¢ at $100K, with no negotiation and no monthly fee.
Watch out for
Online, Stax is already cheaper at $50K ($1,200 vs $1,275). In person, Stax overtakes Helcim between $50K and $250K a month (at $250K: $4,475 vs $4,850).
2. Stax (Fattmerchant)
2.11% in person, 2.40% online at $50K (1.79% and 2.08% at $250K)Subscription interchange-plusBest for
Online sales across this tier, and in-person sales toward the top of it, with predictable monthly volume.
Watch out for
The $199+ subscription is fixed regardless of volume, so slow months cost relatively more. Contract length is not published.
3. Payment Depot
Not published (quote only)Interchange-plus by quoteBest for
Merchants who want another interchange-plus quote to price against Helcim and Stax. Its last readable pricing page states $0 setup and no cancellation fees.
Watch out for
Payment Depot publishes no membership or per-sale prices, so you cannot check a quote against a public rate. Get every fee in writing.
4. Negotiated IC++ from an independent ISO
Not published (quote only)Custom interchange-plus-plusBest for
Operators willing to get 3 ISO quotes and run a competitive process. Worth signing only if a quote beats Helcim's and Stax's published prices.
Watch out for
Hidden fees (PCI, regulatory, statement) can erase rate savings if you do not push back on them in the contract.
Pricing-model breakdown at $50K to $100K monthly
At $50K to $100K monthly, three pricing models compete: flat rate, interchange-plus with a percentage markup, and subscription interchange-plus with a monthly fee and no percentage markup. Here is the math on each.
Tier 1
Auto-discount IC+
Helcim
$0 monthly fee · Interchange + 0.35% + 7¢ in person, + 0.45% + 20¢ online from $50K; 0.25% + 7¢ and 0.35% + 20¢ from $100K
Best for
In-person sales in the lower part of this tier. No negotiation required.
What’s included
- ·No monthly fee or contract
- ·Volume steps applied automatically
- ·No cancellation fee
- ·No setup or PCI fee
- ·Best for operators who do not want to negotiate
Tier 2
Subscription IC-plus
Stax (Payment Depot by quote only)
$199+ monthly + interchange + 8¢ in person, 15¢ online
Best for
Online sales across this tier; in-person sales toward the top of it.
What’s included
- ·No percentage markup over interchange
- ·Fixed 8¢ in person, 15¢ online per sale
- ·Next business day funding
- ·Predictable monthly fee
- ·Payment Depot: interchange-plus by quote, no published prices
Tier 3
Custom IC++ (3-ISO process)
Independent ISO contracts
Quote-based. No published rates to compare against
Best for
Mature operators with stable history, a good chargeback ratio and the time to negotiate.
What’s included
- ·Worth signing only if it beats Helcim's and Stax's published prices
- ·Custom contract terms (push for no ETF, no auto-renewal)
- ·Ask for every monthly, PCI, statement and regulatory fee in writing
- ·PCI, regulatory and statement fees are negotiable
- ·Run a 3-quote competitive process, then come back to your incumbent
The actual math at $50K to $100K monthly
At $50,000 a month (the bottom of this tier and a point in our engine, at a $50 average sale and 60% credit, 40% debit), the monthly cost in person runs: Helcim $1,020, Stax $1,055, PayPal POS $1,235, Stripe Terminal $1,400, Square $1,450. Online: Stax $1,200, Helcim $1,275, Adyen $1,280, Stripe and Square $1,750. At $250,000 a month, the next point in our engine, Stax costs $4,475 in person and $5,200 online against $4,850 and $6,125 for Helcim, so somewhere between $50K and $250K Stax becomes the cheaper choice in person as well. Independent ISO quotes publish no rates, so we cannot put them in this math: price any quote against these figures before you sign. Interchange-plus figures rest on our interchange estimate (1.55% in person, 1.70% online).
Sources
- myPayAdvisor 2026 Payment Processor Effective Rate Database: open dataset, CC-BY-4.0. View
- myPayAdvisor Research Methodology: card-mix assumption, sample selection, calculation method. View
- Processor public pricing pages (checked Oct 29, 2026): Stripe, Square, Helcim, PayPal, Stax, Adyen, Clover, Authorize.net, Braintree, Shopify Payments. Payment Depot and Worldpay publish no merchant rates.