Who this comparison is for
Growing SMBs where interchange-plus is already well ahead of flat rate and a subscription plan starts to pay for itself on online sales.
Recommended processors for $25K to $50K monthly
The 4 processors below are ordered by published cost and fit at this volume. Effective rates come from our cost engine: a $50 average sale, 60% credit and 40% debit cards, prices checked Oct 2026. See the methodology page for full assumptions.
1. Helcim
2.11% in person, 2.70% online below $50K; 2.04% and 2.55% at $50KInterchange-plusBest for
Primary in-person pick at this tier: no monthly fee, no contract, and the margin drops on its own at $50K a month (to 0.35% + 7¢ in person, 0.45% + 20¢ online).
Watch out for
No instant payout option. Online, Stax costs less at $50K a month in our engine ($1,200 vs $1,275).
2. Stax (Fattmerchant)
2.11% in person, 2.40% online at $50KSubscription IC-plusBest for
Online-heavy businesses toward $50K a month, where the $199+ subscription is small next to the markup it removes.
Watch out for
In person Helcim is still cheaper at $50K ($1,020 vs $1,055), and the fixed subscription weighs more the lower your volume. Stax does not publish its contract length, so get it in writing.
3. Stripe
3.50% online, 2.80% in person at a $50 saleFlat-rate (custom pricing for large volume)Best for
Custom checkout, marketplaces and subscription billing where Stripe's API ecosystem outweighs the rate premium.
Watch out for
At $50K a month you pay about $380 more than Helcim in person and $475 more online in our engine. Stripe offers custom pricing for large volumes without stating a threshold, so ask.
4. Square
2.90% in person, 3.50% online at a $50 saleFlat-rateBest for
Card-present retail or restaurants that want Square's POS software and hardware in one system.
Watch out for
Online it costs 2.9% + 30¢ (3.50% at a $50 sale), against 2.40% to 2.55% for Stax and Helcim at $50K. In person Helcim is $430 a month cheaper at $50K.
Pricing-model breakdown at $25K to $50K monthly
At $25K to $50K monthly, three pricing models compete: flat rate, interchange-plus with a percentage markup, and subscription interchange-plus with a monthly fee and no percentage markup. Here is the math on each.
Tier 1
Interchange-plus (no monthly)
Helcim
$0 monthly fee · Interchange + 0.40% + 8¢ in person, + 0.50% + 25¢ online under $50K
Best for
In-person sales across this tier. Best entry point to IC+.
What’s included
- ·No monthly fee or contract
- ·Margin steps down automatically at $50K a month
- ·No setup, PCI or cancellation fee
- ·Real interchange pass-through statements
- ·Cheapest in person at $50K in our engine
Tier 2
Subscription IC-plus
Stax (Payment Depot by quote only)
$199+ monthly at this volume + interchange + 8¢ in person, 15¢ online
Best for
Online-heavy businesses toward $50K a month, where it already beats Helcim.
What’s included
- ·No percentage markup over interchange
- ·Fixed 8¢ in person, 15¢ online per sale
- ·Next business day funding
- ·Contract length not published: ask in writing
- ·Payment Depot: interchange-plus by quote, no published prices
Tier 3
Custom IC++
Negotiated with an ISO
Quote-based. No published rates to compare against
Best for
$45K+ monthly with stable processing history and a good chargeback ratio.
What’s included
- ·Worth signing only if it beats Helcim's and Stax's published prices
- ·Ask for no auto-renewal and no early termination fee in writing
- ·Compare the full quote, including monthly, PCI and statement fees
- ·Worth negotiating only if you process consistently
- ·Get quotes from 3 ISOs before signing
The actual math at $25K to $50K monthly
At $50,000 a month (the top of this tier and a point in our engine, at a $50 average sale and 60% credit, 40% debit), the monthly cost in person runs: Helcim $1,020, Stax $1,055, PayPal POS $1,235, Clover $1,335 (Retail Growth plan), Stripe Terminal $1,400, Square $1,450 (Plus plan). Online: Stax $1,200, Helcim $1,275, Adyen $1,280 (minimum monthly invoice not published), PayPal Advanced card $1,735, Stripe and Square $1,750. Below $50K Helcim's rate holds at 2.11% in person and 2.70% online, while Stax's $199+ subscription weighs more the lower your volume. Interchange-plus figures rest on our interchange estimate (1.55% in person, 1.70% online), so a rewards-heavy card mix costs more.
Sources
- myPayAdvisor 2026 Payment Processor Effective Rate Database: open dataset, CC-BY-4.0. View
- myPayAdvisor Research Methodology: card-mix assumption, sample selection, calculation method. View
- Processor public pricing pages (checked Oct 29, 2026): Stripe, Square, Helcim, PayPal, Stax, Adyen, Clover, Authorize.net, Braintree, Shopify Payments. Payment Depot and Worldpay publish no merchant rates.