Who this comparison is for
Solo operators, small e-commerce and single-location retail crossing the $10K monthly bar, where a no-monthly-fee interchange-plus account already costs less than flat rate but a subscription plan is still hard to justify.
Recommended processors for $10K to $25K monthly
The 4 processors below are ordered by published cost and fit at this volume. Effective rates come from our cost engine: a $50 average sale, 60% credit and 40% debit cards, prices checked Oct 2026. See the methodology page for full assumptions.
1. Helcim
2.11% in person, 2.70% online at $10KInterchange-plusBest for
Primary pick at this tier. Interchange + 0.40% + 8¢ in person and 0.50% + 25¢ online, no monthly fee, no contract. Cheapest in person in our engine at $10K a month and cheaper online than Square, Stripe and PayPal.
Watch out for
No instant payout option (deposits arrive free the next business morning). The rate moves with your card mix, and the 25¢ online fixed fee weighs more on small tickets.
2. Square
2.90% in person, 3.50% online at a $50 saleFlat-rateBest for
Brick-and-mortar retail, restaurants and salons that want Square's POS software and hardware in one system.
Watch out for
In person it is 2.6% + 15¢; online 2.9% + 30¢ on paid plans or 3.3% + 30¢ on Free. At $10K in person it costs $290 a month against $211 for Helcim in our engine.
3. Stripe
3.50% online, 2.80% in person at a $50 saleFlat-rateBest for
Online-only operators, SaaS, marketplaces and subscription billing that need Stripe's developer tools.
Watch out for
2.9% + 30¢ online and 2.7% + 5¢ in person (Terminal). Standard payouts take 2 business days; Instant Payouts cost 1.5%. Online it costs $350 a month at $10K against $270 for Helcim.
4. PayPal
3.47% online (Advanced card), 2.47% in person at a $50 saleFlat-rateBest for
Adding PayPal as a secondary checkout option to capture buyers who prefer paying with PayPal. PayPal POS (2.29% + 9¢) is also the cheapest flat rate in person.
Watch out for
PayPal Checkout costs 3.49% + 49¢, which is 5.94% on a $20 sale. Advanced card processing (2.89% + 29¢) and PayPal POS are subject to PayPal's approval.
Pricing-model breakdown at $10K to $25K monthly
At $10K to $25K monthly, three pricing models compete: flat rate, interchange-plus with a percentage markup, and subscription interchange-plus with a monthly fee and no percentage markup. Here is the math on each.
Tier 1
Entry flat-rate
Square / Stripe / PayPal
$0 monthly fee · 2.29% to 2.7% + 5¢ to 15¢ in person, 2.89% to 2.9% + 29¢ to 30¢ online
Best for
Merchants who value one fixed rate per sale over the lowest cost.
What’s included
- ·No monthly fee on the entry plans
- ·Same percentage at any volume
- ·Square 2.6% + 15¢, Stripe 2.7% + 5¢, PayPal POS 2.29% + 9¢ in person
- ·Square: next-business-day transfers free
- ·Stripe: standard payouts in 2 business days
Tier 2
Mid-tier interchange-plus
Helcim
$0 monthly fee · Interchange + 0.40% + 8¢ in person, + 0.50% + 25¢ online
Best for
The whole tier. Cheaper than Square, Stripe and PayPal at $10K a month in our engine, in person and online.
What’s included
- ·No monthly fee or contract
- ·Margin steps down automatically from $50K a month
- ·No setup, PCI or cancellation fee
- ·Real interchange pass-through
- ·Free next-business-morning deposits
Tier 3
Subscription IC-plus
Stax (Payment Depot by quote only)
$99 to $199+ monthly by annual volume + interchange + 8¢ in person, 15¢ online
Best for
Usually not yet. At $10K a month Stax costs $270 in person and $299 online in our engine, against $211 and $270 for Helcim.
What’s included
- ·No percentage markup over interchange
- ·Subscription rises from $99 to $199+ as annual volume grows
- ·Next business day funding
- ·Contract length not published: ask in writing
- ·Payment Depot: interchange-plus by quote, no published prices
The actual math at $10K to $25K monthly
At $10,000 a month (the nearest point in our engine, at a $50 average sale and 60% credit, 40% debit), the monthly cost in person runs: Helcim $211, PayPal POS $247, Stax $270, Stripe Terminal $280, Square $290 (Free plan). Online: Adyen $256, Helcim $270, Stax $299, PayPal Advanced card $347, Stripe and Square $350. Adyen applies a minimum monthly invoice it does not publish, so small merchants may not qualify. Helcim's margin and the flat rates do not change below $50K a month, so at $25,000 in person Helcim (2.11%) still costs about $198 a month less than Square (2.90%). Interchange-plus figures rest on our interchange estimate (1.55% in person, 1.70% online), so a rewards-heavy card mix costs more.
Sources
- myPayAdvisor 2026 Payment Processor Effective Rate Database: open dataset, CC-BY-4.0. View
- myPayAdvisor Research Methodology: card-mix assumption, sample selection, calculation method. View
- Processor public pricing pages (checked Oct 29, 2026): Stripe, Square, Helcim, PayPal, Stax, Adyen, Clover, Authorize.net, Braintree, Shopify Payments. Payment Depot and Worldpay publish no merchant rates.