TL;DR
For U.S. ecommerce operators, interchange-plus and subscription pricing beat flat rates at every volume in our dataset. Helcim wins on effective rate up to about $50K a month card-not-present, with no monthly fee or contract: 2.70 percent at $10K against 3.50 percent for Stripe. Stax wins from $50K a month, when its subscription costs less than a percentage markup. Stripe wins for global or developer-heavy stacks, not on price. PayPal stays a checkout-button add-on, not a primary processor. Square fits small omnichannel sellers. Worldpay quotes custom contracts for large merchants.
How we ranked
Five weighted criteria. First, effective rate at $250K monthly card-not-present volume, taken from our effective-rate dataset, which assumes a $50 average sale, a mix of 60 percent credit and 40 percent debit, and a 1.70 percent online interchange estimate. Second, contract length and early termination fee, since multi-year deals with termination fees trap merchants when better pricing arrives. Third, settlement speed, with next-day standard and any held-funds reserve flagged. Fourth, Level 2 and Level 3 data support, which matters on commercial cards: on Visa corporate and purchasing cards, the Visa schedule effective Oct 24, 2026 lists Commercial Product 3 at 1.75% + $0.10 against 2.70% + $0.10 for Commercial Card Not Present. See also the Visa interchange schedule and the Mastercard interchange tables. Fifth, hardware and platform lock-in, including proprietary gateways that block portability. We pulled headline pricing from each processor's public page; prices checked Oct 2026.
At a glance
Headline rates are from the processor's public pricing page; prices checked Oct 2026. Effective rates at $250K monthly will differ based on your card mix.
| Provider | Headline pricing | Contract | Settlement | Best for | Watch out for |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Stripe | 2.9% + $0.30 online | None | 2 business days | Developer-heavy and global stacks, marketplaces, SaaS | 3.50% effective at a $50 sale, at every volume |
| Helcim | IC + 0.50% + $0.25 | None | Next business morning | Ecommerce up to about $50K a month | No instant payout option |
| Stax | $99 to $199+/mo by annual volume + IC + $0.15 online | No cancellation fee; length not published | Next business day | $50K and up, predictable count | Subscription weighs on low volume |
| PayPal | 3.49% + $0.49 Checkout | None | Standard withdrawal free; instant 1.5% | Wallet button add-on | Possible holds on new accounts |
| Square | 2.9% + $0.30 online (3.3% + $0.30 on Free) | None | Next business day | Small omnichannel sellers | Instant transfers cost 1.95% |
| Payment Depot | Interchange-plus by quote; no prices listed | No cancellation fees; $0 setup | Not published | Buyers who will get a full written quote | Full cost not public |
| Worldpay | Custom pricing (contact sales) | Negotiated | Negotiated | Large merchants, B2B mix | No published prices |
Stripe
Stripe charges 2.9 percent plus $0.30 on its standard online rate, per its published pricing. At $250K monthly card-not-present volume in our dataset, that works out to 3.50 percent, or $8,750 a month, against $6,125 for Helcim and $5,200 for Stax. That is $31,500 a year more than Helcim. There is no monthly fee and no contract. The Stripe Connect, Billing, and Issuing stack is the strongest in this set for marketplaces, SaaS, and embedded payment platforms. Stripe accepts payments in 135-plus currencies without third-party plugins. The trade-off shows up on rate. Stripe's pricing page offers IC+ and custom pricing for large-volume businesses but publishes no threshold, so ask once your volume grows; the public page is not the only menu. Best for: global or developer-heavy stacks, marketplaces, SaaS billing. Watch out for: a 1.5 percent fee on international cards plus 1 percent when currency conversion applies, an extra 0.5 percent on manually entered cards, and a $15 dispute fee plus $15 more to counter it (refunded if you win).
Helcim
Helcim publishes a card-not-present rate of interchange plus 0.50 percent plus $0.25 per transaction under $50K a month, with automatic volume discounts that step the margin down at $50K, $100K, $500K and $1M. See the Helcim pricing page. No monthly fee, no contract, no ETF. On a $250K monthly card-not-present book, our dataset puts Helcim at 2.45 percent, or $6,125 a month. That is 1.05 points below Stripe at the same volume, or $31,500 a year saved. Helcim processes for U.S. and Canadian merchants and supports ACH (0.5 percent plus $0.25, capped at $6), recurring billing (an extra 0.4 percent per recurring transaction), hosted checkout, and a developer API. Its Level 2/3 optimization runs automatically and keeps 30 percent of the savings it produces. The merchant dashboard surfaces interchange-line detail by transaction, which is the disclosure flat-rate processors do not give. Best for: U.S. ecommerce up to about $50K monthly that wants real interchange-plus without sales calls. Watch out for: there is no instant payout option, interchange-plus means your rate moves with the card mix, and from $50K a month Stax costs less in our dataset.
A merchant doing $250K monthly online pays 3.50 percent on Stripe in our dataset, or $8,750. The same volume on Helcim's interchange-plus tier comes to 2.45 percent, or $6,125. The gap is $2,625 a month, or $31,500 a year.
Stax
Stax charges a monthly subscription of $99 up to $150,000 a year in volume, $139 up to $250,000 and $199 or more above that, and passes interchange straight through with $0.15 per card-not-present transaction, per its public pricing. The subscription model becomes attractive once monthly volume passes somewhere between $10K and $50K, because the fixed cost spreads thin and the percentage markup goes to zero. At $250K monthly with a $50 average sale, that is 5,000 transactions: $199 plus $750 in per-transaction fees plus about $4,250 in interchange at our 1.70 percent estimate, or $5,200 in our dataset. That works out to 2.08 percent effective, 0.37 points below Helcim at the same volume. Stax includes a virtual terminal, hosted invoicing, and a payments API, and charges 1 percent capped at $10 for ACH. Best for: ecommerce from $50K monthly with predictable transaction count and an average ticket above $40. Watch out for: the subscription is real overhead at low volumes (at $10K a month Stax is 2.99 percent against 2.70 percent for Helcim), and the pricing page does not publish a contract length. Read the agreement and any hardware addendum line by line before signing.
PayPal
PayPal's PayPal Checkout rate is 3.49 percent plus $0.49, and its Advanced Credit and Debit card rate is 2.89 percent plus $0.29 (subject to PayPal's approval), per its business fee page. At a $50 average sale, PayPal Checkout works out to 4.47 percent, the most expensive in this comparison: 0.97 points above Stripe and 2.02 points above Helcim at $250K a month. The reason most ecommerce sites still install PayPal is the consumer-side trust signal at checkout: many buyers already have a PayPal account. Test whether the button lifts your own conversion. Treat PayPal as a wallet button on top of a primary processor, not as the primary processor itself. PayPal can hold payments for new or higher-risk sellers. Best for: a secondary checkout button alongside Helcim, Stripe, or Stax. Watch out for: chargebacks cost $20 each, and international sales add 1.5 percent.
Running PayPal Checkout as your primary card-not-present rail on a $250K monthly book costs about $11,175 a month at a $50 average sale (4.47 percent), against $6,125 on Helcim's interchange-plus in our dataset. That is $5,050 a month, or $60,600 a year. Use PayPal as a wallet, not a processor.
Square
Square's online rate is 2.9 percent plus $0.30 on paid plans and the Online API, identical headline pricing to Stripe, and 3.3 percent plus $0.30 on the Free plan, per its published rates. In-person is 2.6 percent plus $0.15 on Free, and keyed runs 3.5 percent plus $0.15 for the manually entered card path. Square's edge is the free POS and the omnichannel inventory sync between online and storefront, not the price. For an ecommerce-only merchant, there is no rate advantage versus Stripe and you lose Stripe's developer tooling. For an omnichannel seller with a single physical location and a $20K to $60K monthly online book, Square consolidates hardware, online checkout, payroll, and gift cards under one account, which has real ops value. Best for: small omnichannel sellers up to $60K monthly online volume with a retail front. Watch out for: instant or same-day transfers cost 1.95 percent, and like any aggregator Square can hold funds when activity changes sharply.
Payment Depot
Payment Depot sells interchange-plus pricing by quote. Its pricing page (archived Oct 2025) lists no monthly or per-transaction price, only $0 setup and no cancellation fees, so the full cost and its effective rate cannot be worked out from public information. Best for: merchants who want interchange-plus pricing and will get a full written quote. Watch out for: ask whether hardware, gateway or monthly fees are billed on top of the quoted rate, and request the full schedule in writing before signing, then compare it with Stax's and Helcim's published costs.
Worldpay
Worldpay has been part of Global Payments since January 2026, when Global Payments completed its purchase from FIS and GTCR. It sells custom contracts and does not publish a flat retail rate on its corporate site. Contract length, termination fees, and onboarding time are all negotiated, so get each in writing. Worldpay's value shows up at enterprise volume, where Level 3 data support, multi-currency settlement, and negotiated pricing can matter on commercial card spend. Best for: large ecommerce merchants with international or B2B card-not-present mix. Watch out for: without a published price list there is nothing to compare until you have a written quote, and for smaller merchants the contract terms rarely justify the effort over a published interchange-plus offering.
Verdict
For U.S. ecommerce operators up to about $50K a month, Helcim wins on effective rate, contract terms, and statement transparency. The interchange-plus structure means your rate moves with the network's published wholesale rates, not with a flat margin that the processor keeps when interchange falls. From $50K a month, Stax wins on cost in our dataset, where its subscription costs less than Helcim's percentage. Stripe wins when global coverage matters or when the engineering team needs the Stripe API surface, not on price. PayPal stays a wallet button; do not let it run as your primary card-not-present processor. Worldpay quotes custom contracts for large merchants. Square fits small omnichannel sellers under $60K monthly online. The annual saving between Stripe's flat rate and Helcim's interchange-plus at $250K a month is $31,500 in our dataset, so a rate audit usually pays for itself in month one.
Before switching, pull your last three monthly statements, calculate effective rate (total fees divided by total volume), and request a written rate sheet from any new processor that itemizes interchange pass-through, processor markup, per-transaction fee, monthly fee, gateway fee, and PCI fee separately.