TL;DR

For restaurants under about $25K a month, Square wins on out-of-the-box restaurant POS, tip workflow, and zero setup cost, though its 2.6% + 15¢ in-person rate is the highest in our cost engine. From about $10K to $250K a month, Helcim is the cheapest in our engine, with no contract or hardware lock, but it sells no restaurant POS software. From $250K a month, Stax's subscription ($199 or more a month at that volume) with pass-through interchange is the cheapest. Clover's Growth bundles cost less per sale than Square if you accept a 36-month hardware subscription. Stripe and PayPal fit online ordering better than the dining room. Prices checked Oct 2026.

How we ranked

Restaurants are a payment vertical with quirks that do not appear in retail. Three matter most: tip adjustment after the card runs, settlement speed against thin cash cycles, and the cost of a hardware swap when you switch processors.

Six criteria, in order of weight:

  1. Effective rate at $50K and $250K a month in person, from our ranking engine: a $50 average sale, 60 percent credit and 40 percent debit, and a stated interchange estimate of 1.55 percent. Prices checked Oct 2026.
  2. Contract length and early termination fee. Below 12 months at zero ETF earns full marks.
  3. Hardware portability. Can you reprogram the POS to a new processor? Clover and Stripe Terminal are locked. Square hardware works only with Square.
  4. Tip adjustment workflow for sit-down service.
  5. Online ordering integration. Native or one-click to Toast, Olo, Square Online, or Stripe Checkout.
  6. Surcharge and cash-discount compliance with state law and Visa or Mastercard rules.

Feature counts were not weighted. What shows up on the monthly statement was.

At a glance

Six providers, ordered from smallest to largest volume fit. Pricing from each provider's public page, prices checked Oct 2026.

ProviderHeadline pricingContractSettlementBest forWatch out for
Square2.6% + $0.15 in-person on Free; 2.5% + $0.15 on Plus ($49/mo per location)NoneNext day freeUnder $25K, QSR and full-serviceHardware locked to Square
Clover2.3% to 2.6% + $0.10 plus $0 to $89.95+/mo software36-month hardware subscription on Clover.com1 to 3 days; Rapid Deposit 1.75%Countertop POS, hardware ownersBank and reseller terms can differ; device lock
Stripe2.7% + $0.05 in-person; 2.9% + $0.30 onlineNone2 business daysOnline ordering, ghost kitchensNo native restaurant POS
HelcimIC + 0.40% + $0.08 in-personNoneNext business morning$10K to $250K monthlyNo restaurant-specific POS software
Stax$99 to $199+/mo by annual volume + IC + $0.08 in-personNo cancellation fee stated; length not publishedNext business day$250K+ monthlyMonthly fee hurts under $50K
Payment DepotInterchange-plus by quote; no prices listedNo cancellation fees; $0 setupNot publishedMerchants with a written quoteFull cost not public

Square

Square charges 2.6 percent plus 15 cents per in-person transaction on its $0 Free plan (2.5 percent plus 15 cents on Plus) and 3.3 percent plus 30 cents online on Free (2.9 percent plus 30 cents on paid plans), per Square's pricing page. Keyed card-not-present runs 3.5 percent plus 15 cents. The free POS app handles tips, splits, and items. Square Plus costs $49 a month per location, and Square's restaurant pricing page lists features such as coursing and seat management, tableside ordering, and tip pooling, with the Square KDS app at $20 a month per device.

What a restaurant gets for the 2.6 percent rate: next-business-day funding at no extra cost, no monthly fee on the base plan, no contract, and no ETF. Tip adjustment is built into the POS, and Square's restaurant page says staff can claim the cash tips they earn.

Watch out

Square hardware runs only on Square. A Square Register has no resale value to a competing processor. If you outgrow the flat rate, you write off the hardware when you switch.

Best for: Quick-service, fast-casual, and single-location full-service under about $25K monthly, where free POS software matters more than the rate.

Avoid if: You process well above $25K a month and cost comes first. At $50K a month in person, our engine puts Square Plus at about $1,450 against $1,020 on Helcim.

Clover

Clover is a POS platform owned by Fiserv. Clover is also sold through banks and resellers, whose rates and terms can differ from Clover.com. Rates posted on Clover's pricing page show 2.3 to 2.6 percent plus 10 cents in-person and 3.5 percent plus 10 cents keyed, with software from $0 on Starter to $89.95 or more a month on Restaurant Growth (prices checked Oct 2026). On the Growth bundles, our engine puts Clover at about $1,335 a month at $50K in person, below Square's $1,450. What a reseller bills you against those rates can be a different number.

Hardware: Clover Go at $199, Compact at $349 or $16 a month for 36 months, and Station Solo bundles from $1,799. Clover hardware runs on Clover's own processing, and Clover.com hardware subscriptions run 36 months and cannot be canceled.

Example

For example, if a switch later saves 0.30 percent on $250,000 a month, that is $750 a month, or $9,000 a year. Weigh that against the hardware you would replace and any months left on a 36-month subscription.

Best for: A merchant who already has Clover hardware on the floor and a reasonable processing contract, or who wants countertop hardware and accepts a 36-month term.

Avoid if: You will not commit to a 3-year hardware term. Always read the contract: bank and reseller terms can differ from Clover.com.

Stripe

Stripe charges 2.9 percent plus 30 cents online and 2.7 percent plus 5 cents in-person on Terminal, per Stripe's pricing page. There is no monthly fee and no contract. Funding runs on a 2-business-day rolling schedule by default.

Where Stripe wins for restaurants: online ordering for ghost kitchens, multi-brand virtual concepts, and direct-to-consumer subscription meal kits. Stripe Checkout and Stripe Connect are the cleanest API for splitting payouts across multiple vendors or kitchens out of one ordering domain. If you run a delivery-first operation and want to skip Toast or Olo, Stripe is the toolchain.

Where Stripe loses: in-store dine-in. Stripe Terminal hardware does not run a native restaurant POS. You pair it with a third-party POS built on Stripe Terminal and pay Stripe's processing rate. At $250K a month in person, our engine puts Stripe at about $7,000 against $4,850 on Helcim and $4,475 on Stax.

Best for: Online-only restaurants, ghost kitchens, and multi-tenant ordering platforms that need programmable payouts.

Avoid if: You run a sit-down dining room and want one POS vendor for front-of-house and back-of-house.

Helcim

Helcim publishes some of the clearest pricing of any U.S. processor that accepts restaurants. In-person runs interchange plus 0.40 percent plus 8 cents; online runs interchange plus 0.50 percent plus 25 cents, per Helcim's pricing page. Volume discounts apply automatically from $50K monthly, with no contract, no monthly fee, and no ETF.

Example

At $250K a month in person, our engine puts Helcim at 1.94 percent, about $4,850 a month. Square Premium on the same volume is about $6,900, roughly $2,050 a month more, or $73,800 over 36 months.

The catch: no native restaurant POS. Helcim's Smart Terminal ($349) takes card-present payments, but the front-of-house workflow (table maps, course firing, 86 lists) requires a third-party POS connected by API. Helcim hardware is portable across Helcim-processed locations.

Best for: Restaurants from about $10K to $250K a month that already run a POS they like and want to drop the processing rate.

Avoid if: You want POS software from the same vendor as the processor. Helcim does not sell that.

Stax

Stax (formerly Fattmerchant) charges $99 a month up to $150,000 a year in volume, $139 from $150,000 to $250,000, and $199 or more above that, plus interchange plus 8 cents in-person and 15 cents online, per Stax's pricing page. There is no percentage markup over interchange. The model works best at higher volume, where the monthly fee is spread over more sales.

At $250K a month in person, our engine puts Stax at 1.79 percent, about $4,475 a month including the subscription, against 1.94 percent ($4,850) on Helcim. At $1M the figures are about $17,300 and $18,200. Ask Stax which restaurant POS systems it supports; its pricing page lists a SwipeSimple reader at $125 and Dejavoo QD4 and QD2 terminals at $310 and $495.

Watch out

Stax's pricing page states no cancellation fees but does not publish the contract length. Get the term in writing before you sign.

Best for: Restaurants from about $250K a month, multi-location operators, banquet and event venues with high ticket sizes.

Avoid if: You process under about $50K a month. At $10K the fee pushes Stax to about $270 a month in our engine, above Helcim's $211.

Payment Depot

Payment Depot sells interchange-plus pricing by quote. Payment Depot's pricing page (archived Oct 2025) lists no monthly or per-transaction price; it says $0 setup and no cancellation fees, so we cannot compute its full cost.

The comparison with Stax depends on the quote you get, so set it against Stax's published subscription plus interchange and 8 cents in person. Ask which terminals it supports before you buy hardware.

Settlement timing is not published on its pricing page. Read the agreement before signing.

Best for: Restaurants that want pass-through interchange and can get the full quote in writing.

Avoid if: You want a single-vendor stack (processor plus POS plus hardware).

Verdict

Three pricing models compete for restaurants in 2026: flat-rate (Square, Stripe, PayPal), interchange-plus with no monthly fee (Helcim), and subscription with pass-through interchange (Stax). Payment Depot also sells interchange-plus, but by quote only. The right answer is volume.

Under about $25K a month, Square wins on simplicity, restaurant POS, and the absence of a monthly fee, even though its rate is the highest in our engine. From about $10K to $250K a month, Helcim is the cheapest in our engine with no contract or hardware penalty: about $1,020 a month at $50K in person, against $1,450 on Square Plus. From $250K a month, Stax is the cheapest: about $4,475 against $4,850 on Helcim, because its subscription is spread over more sales than Helcim's markup. Prices checked Oct 2026.

Clover's Growth bundles cost less per sale than Square, about $1,335 a month at $50K, if you want countertop hardware and accept a 36-month hardware subscription. Toast's published Traditional plan, 2.49 percent plus 15 cents plus $69 a month, works out to about $1,464 at $50K on the same formula, with a 2-year agreement; see Clover vs Toast. Stripe is the right answer for delivery-only and multi-tenant ordering platforms. Payment Depot sells interchange-plus by quote only, so get a written quote.

Three restaurant payment issues: tip adjustment, settlement speed, and hardware lock-in.
Three restaurant payment issues: tip adjustment, settlement speed, and hardware lock-in.